I had a good look at your site and I can see absolutely nothing wrong. It's definitely not the problems of the meta tags, you have some inbound links, you are listed on Yahoo and MSN... just for some reason you don't even exist in Google

It defintely looks like your site got banned however I can see no reason why...
PPP says he can still see the redirect... Hmm, I can't see any...
http://www.buckeyereport.com/ seems to be a bit of clean simple html with a link to
http://www.ohiostatepoker.com/ - that can't cause any problems... Honestly I have no idea what can...
I can see no reason to apply a 301 redirect as it is used to transfer page rank. In this case we are not looking for page rank, we just want to get indexed!! Maybe it would be better to completely anihilate the
http://www.buckeyereport.com/ ?? Can see little logic in that, but maybe it will work...